Mining meets biodiversity, and for once somebody actually mapped it
The ICMM has finally put out a global dataset matching 12,000 mining and metals facilities against internationally recognized indicators of ecosystem condition and conservation status. Here’s what this really means: after decades of the industry talking about biodiversity in press releases, there’s now an actual evidence base showing where mines sit relative to the places that matter most for nature. That’s a step forward, and I don’t say that lightly about industry-published research.
The headline numbers are the kind that gets spun in both directions, so let’s cut through it. 22% of facilities sit in landscapes of high or very high ecosystem condition — places where original biodiversity is largely intact and habitats remain connected. 5% intersect Key Biodiversity Areas (KBAs). 4% intersect Protected or Conserved Areas. The industry will tell you those numbers are small. The conservation crowd will tell you they’re damning. Both are missing the point.
This isn’t the first time we’ve seen this circus — an industry commissions its own data, publishes a flattering-sounding fraction, and everyone argues about the denominator. But the underlying methodology here is more honest than usual, because the ICMM itself admits the limitations upfront: the analysis doesn’t measure impact from any individual facility, the indicators can’t isolate a single mine’s contribution to landscape condition, and each facility is plotted as a point, not a footprint. So these figures describe shares of facilities, not area of land disturbed. A point on a map tells you where, not how much. Keep that in mind when anyone quotes these percentages at you with a straight face.
Now, the supply chain differences are where the real money — and the real risk — lives. Antimony, diamond, and lithium operations are overrepresented in high ecosystem condition areas. Platinum group metals, barium, and chromite are underrepresented. Manganese, tin, and diamond facilities are overrepresented in KBAs relative to the global average, while steel, lithium, and coal are proportionally underrepresented. Read that twice, because there’s an uncomfortable irony buried in it: the metals most celebrated by the decarbonisation crowd — lithium, cobalt’s cousins, the whole battery complex — are punching into intact landscapes. The very transition everyone wants to fund has a physical footprint, and that footprint is landing in some of the last untouched places on Earth.
I’ve watched enough commodity cycles to know that capital flows to the story before it flows to the geology. Right now the story is “clean energy minerals,” and governments are throwing permits, subsidies, and strategic designations at anything battery-adjacent. This dataset should be a cold shower for that enthusiasm in specific geographies. If you’re an investor in lithium developers, you should be asking whether your asset sits in a high-condition landscape, because that’s not just an ESG talking point anymore — it’s permitting risk, timeline risk, and increasingly a stranded-capital risk. The era of “dig first, apologize later” is closing, slowly and unevenly, but closing.
Indonesia deserves special mention. 84% of facilities there — mostly thermal coal — are in high ecosystem condition areas also facing pressure from other drivers. That’s a pressure-cooker. Intact habitat, multiple stressors, and an industry with political protection. Anyone who’s watched Indonesian nickel or coal knows the enforcement gap between what’s on paper and what happens on the ground is wide enough to drive a haul truck through.
Then there’s the case that should make everyone squirm: Chrissie Pans in South Africa. A wetland that is 100% irreplaceable for the survival of one species — one species, globally, full stop — and it contains 18 coal facilities, none within a formal protected area. Globally, 73% of the KBAs hosting facilities aren’t fully formally protected, meaning their conservation depends on voluntary standards and corporate commitments. I’ve been in this game long enough to know what voluntary commitments are worth when the commodity price spikes. They’re worth exactly as much as the next quarterly earnings call allows them to be.
Here’s the practical takeaway for anyone allocating capital: unprotected does not mean unimportant, and formal protection can change with a stroke of a legislative pen. Assets clustered in KBAs — 607 facilities across 359 sites, with 12 sites holding six or more facilities each — carry a concentration risk that most analysts haven’t priced. If governments get serious about the Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework, which commits 196 countries to halting the loss of high-integrity landscapes by 2030 and conserving 30% of land and water, those unprotected KBAs with mines in them are the obvious places to draw new boundaries. Regulators move slowly until they move all at once. Ask anyone who held coal assets through the last decade of policy whiplash.
That said, I’m not going to pretend the GBF targets will be met on schedule. 196 countries signed a framework, which in my experience means 196 different implementation timelines and roughly zero enforcement mechanisms. Treat the 2030 deadlines as direction of travel, not certainty. But direction of travel is enough to shift permitting regimes and financing conditions, and that’s what moves asset values.
Credit where due on one point: the ICMM is upfront that the dataset excludes artisanal and small-scale mining, illegal operations, and closed sites. That’s a hole you could lose a small continent in. Artisanal gold alone involves tens of millions of people and wrecks more habitat per ounce than any industrial operation. So when you see headlines saying “only 5% of mines intersect key biodiversity areas,” remember that’s 5% of the formal, mapped, above-board sector. The shadow sector is unmapped by definition, and it’s growing wherever prices make scratching the ground profitable. Dr Emma Gagen, the ICMM’s Director of Data and Research, acknowledges governments need to act on illegal mining and support the informal sector — which is diplomatically phrased, because what it really means is that the industry wants the informal competition regulated out of existence. Cynical? Sure. Also probably necessary for both biodiversity and basic labor standards.
What’s genuinely useful here is the invitation. The ICMM published this so governments, industry, and conservation groups can target collaborative action, and it’s asking companies to contribute facility boundary data so point locations can become actual operational footprints. Footprint data is where the real analysis happens — area disturbed, buffer effects, fragmentation. Points on maps are the trailer; footprints are the film.
My take, for what it’s worth after thirty years of watching industries discover that externalities eventually show up on the income statement: this dataset is a floor, not a ceiling. It’s incomplete, it’s coarse, and it’s published by the industry it describes. But it’s the first global picture, and the first honest picture changes the conversation. The mining sector sits at the sharp end of a contradiction nobody in policy circles wants to say out loud — the energy transition requires digging up the planet on a scale never before attempted, in many cases in the last intact ecosystems we have. You cannot decarbonise without minerals, and you cannot extract minerals without touching land. The only real question is where, how carefully, and under whose rules.
This dataset doesn’t answer that question. But it finally gives everyone the same map to argue over, and that’s more than the sector has managed in a century of digging.

