Layoffs Never End — Guess Profits Don’t Either

11 Min Read

# Continuous Cutting: More Metres, More Progress — But Mind the Hype

There’s a piece making the rounds in the mining trade press arguing that more metres equal more progress in the hard-rock continuous cutting game. Here’s what this really means: the industry is once again trying to drag a proven soft-rock technology — the continuous miner, the roadheader, the shearer — into hard rock, where it has failed repeatedly for sixty years. And once again, the pitch is seductive.

I’ve been watching this circus since the late seventies, when the first serious attempts to mechanize hard-rock cutting came out of South Africa’s gold mines. The gold price was ripping, margins were fat, and everyone wanted the tunneling equivalent of the longwall. What they got was tungsten carbide picks sheared off like matchsticks, machine downtime that would make a hedge fund’s redemptions look tame, and a lot of embarrassed equipment manufacturers quietly writing off R&D budgets.

So when I read that “more metres equal more progress,” my first instinct is to ask: more metres at what cost per metre? Because in mining, as in markets, the headline number and the economic number are rarely the same thing.

## The Actual Case for Continuous Cutting

Strip away the trade-show gloss and the core argument is legitimate. Conventional drill-and-blast is an intermittent process. You drill, you blast, you ventilate, you muck, you support. Each cycle is downtime sandwiched between more downtime. In a deep mine, cycle times stretch, and the advance rate on a development heading can be embarrassingly low — single-digit metres per day is not unusual in tough conditions.

Continuous cutting machines, in theory, eliminate the cycle. Rock is cut mechanically, material is loaded continuously, advance rates climb. For soft to medium rock — coal, potash, soft shale — this is settled science. Caterpillar (via the Joy acquisition), Sandvik, Komatsu, and others sell machines that perform exactly this way in suitable ground.

The hard-rock problem is a materials problem, not a concept problem. Rock with compressive strength above roughly 120–140 MPa chews through cutting tools. Pick consumption goes exponential. Every tool change is a stoppage. When your pick consumption hits one tool per tonne cut instead of one per hundred tonnes, your machine becomes a very expensive excuse to stand still.

## Why This Time Might Be Different — Emphasis on Might

Here’s where the current optimism has some substance, and I’ll give it credit where due. Three things have genuinely moved.

First, cutting tool technology. There’s been real progress in tool materials and cooling — thermally stable materials, better carbide grades, tool designs that manage heat rather than fighting it. Rio Tinto, as part of its large-scale remote-ops ambitions, spent years on rapid mine development programs specifically testing hard-rock cutting tools at scale. That wasn’t marketing; that was serious money grinding through trials in real ore.

Second, machine power and cutterhead design. Modern machines bring more installed power to the cutting face and distribute it more intelligently across tool spacing. And the mechanized cutting and bolting platforms — Sandvik’s hard-rock continuous machines, for example — combine cutting with ground support installation, which addresses the follow-on bottleneck. Cutting rock fast is useless if your roof support can’t keep pace and your safety folks shut you down.

Third, the economics have shifted. Labor is scarcer and more expensive. Grade control matters more as orebodies get deeper and uglier. A continuous process that’s narrower per metre than drill-and-blast also means less dilution, less overbreak, less ground damage — and ground damage is a hidden liability that conventional accounting ignores until the stope collapses.

## What the Skeptic in Me Says

Now, the sober part. This isn’t the first time we’ve seen this circus, and each prior incarnation came with a stock of optimistic press releases followed by quiet withdrawal.

The rock cutting business has a graveyard: the Australian CSIRO machines, the South African gold-mining trials of the eighties and nineties, the various tunnel boring attempts in narrow-vein environments. The technology didn’t fail because nobody believed in it. It failed because rock is an unforgiving counterparty. You don’t get to renegotiate the terms when the orebody runs harder than the feasibility study assumed.

Which is precisely the point I’d hammer home to anyone putting money behind this theme: the machine is not the moat. The orebody fit is the moat. A continuous cutter is a financial instrument with geological counterparty risk. If your ground is soft enough and your geometry is regular — long straight drives, competent but cuttable rock, good ventilation access — you can get stunning advances. If your ground is fractured, abrasive, variably hard, or dipping unpredictably, you get a machine that spends more time being repaired than cutting.

The other thing that smells fishy: the “more metres” framing itself. Metres per day is a vanity metric unless it’s tied to tonnes delivered to the mill, on schedule, at budget. The mining industry has a long history of optimizing for advance rates and discovering later that the metres were too narrow, too damaged, or too dilute to matter. I’ve seen junior companies trumpet development metres to keep the story alive for the market while the cost per metre quietly doubled. If someone pitches you continuous cutting on metres alone, ask for the cost per metre, tool consumption per tonne, availability percentages, and the maintenance regime. If they can’t produce those numbers, you’re being sold a story, not an asset.

## The Macro Case — Why the Money Is Actually Flowing

Let’s be fair to the bulls on one macro point. The inputs to this technology wave are real.

Battery metals demand has driven deep, hot, hard deposits into the project pipeline — nickel, copper, and lithium-hosting ground where shallow, soft deposits are gone. Deep mines mean heat, which means ventilation is the binding constraint, which means the smaller excavation footprint of mechanical cutting (versus the overbreak of blasting) genuinely helps. Less rock moved per ore tonne means less ventilation duty, less cooling load, lower energy cost per tonne. In a deep mine, that’s material to the operating margin.

Also real: the labor story. Drill-and-blast crews are aging out faster than they’re being replaced. Every mining executive I’ve talked to in the last decade says the same thing — the crews aren’t there. Mechanization isn’t a nice-to-have anymore; it’s existential. If continuous cutting can deliver acceptable advance rates with half the people underground, the industry will force the technology to work through sheer necessity, if nothing else.

And autonomous operation plays naturally with continuous cutting. A machine that cuts on a consistent, repeatable profile is easier to automate than a drill-and-blast cycle with all its variability. The software story rides on the hardware story.

## The Risk Framework — How I’d Underwrite It

For those of you looking at exposure here — through equipment makers, juniors adopting the technology, or service providers — here’s how I’d think about it.

Concentration matters. The viable applications are narrower than the marketing suggests. Look for deployments in sedimentary or medium-strength rock, regular geometry, mine plans that suit continuous advance. Ignore the pitch decks promising hard-rock cutting “everywhere.”

Watch tool consumption per tonne as your leading indicator. That single number tells you whether the materials science is winning or the geology is. When it trends down across a fleet, the economics compound. When it holds steady or climbs, you’re subsidizing a science project.

Watch availability, not just advance rate. A machine that cuts 40 metres in a week and spends three days down has worse economics than one that cuts 25 metres steadily, once you account for maintenance staffing, spares inventory, and the capital tied up in downtime.

And watch the financial structure of the vendors. Several of these machines are sold on performance guarantees or pay-per-metre models. That’s fine when it works, but it loads balance-sheet risk onto the OEM when the ground misbehaves. Check who’s carrying the geology risk.

## The Bottom Line

The core argument — more metres equal more progress — is directionally correct but economically incomplete. Continuous cutting in hard rock is a real, advancing technology with genuine tailwinds: better tools, better machines, scarcer labor, hotter and deeper orebodies. It is also a technology with a long, expensive history of overpromising, and the geology of the deposits it targets hasn’t gotten any friendlier.

My stance is the one I take with most paradigm-shift pitches in this industry: acknowledge the trend, demand the cost curve, size the position for a technology that will win unevenly, mine by mine, over a decade — not a revolution that arrives on schedule. The rock doesn’t read press releases. Neither should you.

Source: https://im-mining.com/2026/11/17/feature-article-continuous-cutting-2/

Share This Article
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *